Guides · More reading
Do you have to be in the state fund?
Probably not — and most businesses that could leave never find out. Here's how businesses end up in the state fund, why they stay long after they need to, and how to tell when your couple of clean years is worth real money. If you'd rather skip to the answer for your business, text the number up top.
Ben Page · Idaho Falls & South Jordan · licensed in Idaho and Utah
If you read nothing else
The state fund is where businesses start, not where they have to stay. If you've got two or three years behind you and a decent claims record, the regular market wants your business — and finding out what that's worth costs one text.
How everybody ends up there
The state fund takes the businesses other companies won't: brand-new operations with no work comp history, rough claims records, tough industries. That's its job, and it does it well — when you opened, it was probably the door that was open. Nothing wrong with any of that. The problem isn't starting there. The problem is that nobody ever tells you when you've outgrown it.
Why nobody leaves
Here's the quiet truth of my industry: once your policy is in force somewhere, re-shopping it is work — and plenty of agents find it more convenient to leave you where you are. Renewal comes, the bill gets paid, nobody asks the question. I've moved businesses that had been in the state fund for a decade past the point they needed to be — not because anyone did anything wrong, but because no one was looking.
What the regular market looks like
The state funds of Idaho and Utah write a piece of the work comp in these states — dozens of regular, A-rated companies write the rest, and they compete for businesses with a little history and a decent record. What that competition buys you, beyond price: no big deposit up front, pay-as-you-go billing off your real payroll (it links to QuickBooks or most any accounting system), simpler payroll reporting, and with some companies, money back in good years — never guaranteed, but real when it happens. Restaurants and contractors with a decent record who moved their work comp to me have saved up to 40%. Not everyone saves that much; it depends on your record and your operation.
When to ask the question
Two markers: you've been operating for at least a couple of years, and your claims record is decent. Hit both and it's time to look — and it's worth re-asking every few years even if the answer was no once, because companies change their appetite constantly. A handful of states do force businesses into a state fund — Idaho and Utah aren't among them. Here, staying is a choice; it should at least be an informed one.
What asking actually involves
Text me. I'll tell you what I'd need — usually your current dec page and a rough payroll picture — and then I'll tell you straight whether moving is worth it for you. If the state fund is genuinely your best home right now, I'll say that too, and you'll know instead of wondering.
Been in the state fund more than a couple of years? The question costs nothing.
The state fund is a starting line, not a sentence.
Why work comp costs what it does →
General information, not advice on your specific situation — whether a move makes sense depends on your record, your payroll, and the market's appetite the day we ask.